Neighborhood Guide · Clay County, Florida
Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island
Eagle Harbor is the anchor community of Fleming Island — a large, amenity-heavy golf development wrapped around Doctors Lake and the Clay County school zones that draw families down from Duval. It has enough sales volume that the numbers here actually mean something.
Market snapshot
Ninety-five closings were recorded, the highest count of any Clay County community in this dataset, at a median of $575,000 and about $222 a square foot. Homes averaged 45 days on market with 2.7 months of supply, which the source classifies as a balanced market. Median price was roughly 8% lower than a year earlier — a correction off the peak, on strong volume rather than thin data.
Market figures above are aggregated community sales data taken from the public community-data index published at the website movewithmomentum.com (an unaffiliated third party), dataset generated 2026-07-13, reflecting sales as of 2026-07-09. Figures are area aggregates, not an appraisal or a valuation of any individual home, and they change as new sales record. HOA dues, CDD fees and property taxes are NOT shown here: the only figures available for them are modelled estimates rather than recorded amounts. Ask Chris Moore for the current recorded numbers before you rely on them.
Where it is
- City
- Fleming Island
- County
- Clay County
- Area
- Fleming Island, Clay County
- State
- Florida
What to check before you buy here
Eagle Harbor is made up of many separate villages, and they do not share one fee structure or one product type. Get the specific village's association documents, the amenity fee, and any CDD or special assessment in writing before you commit — the difference between two villages can be several hundred dollars a month.
Thinking about Eagle Harbor?
Chris Moore has Clay County listings on the board right now and knows how the individual Eagle Harbor villages price against each other. If you are weighing Fleming Island against Oakleaf or St. Johns, call and talk it through.
Chris Moore · Sales Associate · Licensed Florida Real Estate Sales Associate SL3389080
More from The Moore Group
Questions about Eagle Harbor
Answered from the figures and sources shown on this page.
How much do homes in Eagle Harbor sell for?
The community sales dataset cited on this page records a median sale price of $575,000 for Eagle Harbor, or about $222 per square foot. These are area aggregates, not an appraisal or a valuation of any individual home, and they change as new sales record.
How long does it take to sell a home in Eagle Harbor?
Homes in Eagle Harbor averaged 45 days on market in the same dataset.
Is Eagle Harbor a buyer’s market or a seller’s market?
The dataset records 2.7 months of supply in Eagle Harbor, which it classes as a Balanced Market.
Have prices in Eagle Harbor risen or fallen over the past year?
Median price in Eagle Harbor read -8% against the prior year in the same dataset.
What city and county is Eagle Harbor in?
Eagle Harbor is in Fleming Island, Clay County, Florida. This page places it in Fleming Island, Clay County.
Everywhere else on The Moore Group
Every guide, market report and neighborhood page on this site, grouped by county.
This site
Guides
Clay County
- Clay County FL housing market data
- 32073 Orange Park FL housing market data
- 32068 Middleburg FL housing market data
- 32656 Keystone Heights FL housing market data
- Schools in Clay County, FL
- Schools in Middleburg, FL
- Things to Do in Middleburg, FL
- Hibernia Plantation, Fleming Island homes for sale
- Two Creeks, Middleburg homes for sale
Duval County
- Duval County FL housing market data
- 32225 Jacksonville FL housing market data
- Schools in Jacksonville, FL
- Things to Do in Jacksonville, FL
- Things to Do in Mandarin, Jacksonville FL
- Chimney Lakes, Jacksonville homes for sale
- Del Webb eTown, Jacksonville homes for sale
- Hardwick Farms, Jacksonville homes for sale